No Criminal Charges Filed Against Panthers Following Failed South Carolina Headquarters Deal

Columbia, South Carolina: Exciting Developments on the Panthers and State Deal

There’s been quite a stir in Columbia lately concerning the Carolina Panthers and their highly-publicized but ultimately failed attempts to move their headquarters to South Carolina. On Monday, officials reported that criminal charges will not be pursued against the Panthers, their owner, David Tepper, or any associated entities.

A Complex Situation Unfolds

According to senior assistant deputy attorney general Creighton Waters, investigations have revealed “no criminal intent on the part of anyone involved” in what some are calling a “boondoggle.” He described the entire scenario as an “unfortunate situation” that ultimately cost South Carolina taxpayers tens of millions of dollars.

This decision comes as a relief for the Panthers franchise, following a tumultuous period after their bid to establish their corporate headquarters and practice facility in Rock Hill, SC. Back in 2019, the agreement was celebrated as a major accomplishment for local government and was heavily promoted by Governor Henry McMaster.

What Went Wrong?

Unfortunately, the enthusiasm surrounding this deal quickly faded when it collapsed, leaving a half-built facility that has since been demolished. This has resulted in an empty 245-acre lot and a disgruntled community, from local politicians to developers. To make matters worse, the Panthers have now decided to relocate their preseason practices from Spartanburg, SC, where they had long been rooted for twenty-eight years, back to Charlotte, NC.

The Investigation and Its Findings

The whole situation reached a boiling point when reports emerged about the investigation, which initially began in December 2022. Allegations indicated that Tepper was attempting to buy local governments’ silence following the failed deal. Specifically, York County was supposed to receive over $21 million from Tepper’s companies, but the receipt of these funds was seemingly tied to local officials remaining uncooperative during the investigation.

In a draft settlement agreement that became public, the county would have to “irrevocably withdraw any prior complaint” against Tepper’s companies, and if they didn’t, there could be significant penalties involved. Concerns bubbled to the surface about whether this amounted to obstruction of justice.

Prosecution Declined

Despite these serious concerns, Waters ultimately decided against prosecution. In his correspondence, he emphasized that while some language in the agreement raised alarms, it acknowledged that the county was free to comply with any legal requirements and cooperate with investigations. He noted that both the county and its officials fully cooperated with their inquiry.

As a result, the investigation concluded without any criminal charges, and it appears Tepper and the Panthers are off the hook, at least for now.

What’s Next?

Meanwhile, Tepper is likely moving forward onto new ventures, whether that involves future interactions in South Carolina or other expansive plans elsewhere. This latest twist in the Panthers saga, however, leaves residents in the Palmetto State pondering the implications of the extensive financial support that was offered and then abruptly withdrawn.

As the dust settles from this chapter, there remains a glimmer of hope that future developments might better benefit the local community economically and socially. It’s a mixture of relief and reflection for South Carolina as lessons learned could lead to smarter decisions moving forward.

In an ever-evolving world of sports economics and corporate deals, we will surely keep our ears to the ground on what happens with David Tepper and the Carolina Panthers. For now, it seems the only thing left to do is sit back and see where the road takes them next.