Rock Hill Community Awaits Judge’s Verdict on Jimar Neely

News Summary

In Rock Hill, SC, tensions mount as a judge is set to decide the fate of Jimar Neely, found not guilty by reason of insanity for a 2019 shooting. Local residents remain divided over his potential release, fearing for community safety while Neely’s defense argues for his freedom due to his mental health treatment. The case highlights critical discussions surrounding mental health and public safety.

Rock Hill on Edge as Judge to Decide Fate of Jimar Neely

In the cozy town of Rock Hill, South Carolina, tensions are running high as a judge prepares to make a crucial decision about the future of Jimar Neely. This case dates back to a harrowing shooting incident in 2019, when Neely took the lives of two men, Tim Barber and Robbin Thompson, while they were merely waiting in their truck. This tragic event continues to resonate with the local community, and now, a verdict looms that could let Neely back into society.

The Background

Back in 2022, after a lengthy legal battle, Neely was found not guilty by reason of insanity, a ruling that shocked many residents. He had been diagnosed with schizophrenia and during the time of the incident, he wasn’t taking the medication mandated by the court. Following the ruling, Neely was sent to a South Carolina Department of Mental Health hospital for treatment, where he has since spent the last three years.

The Legal Fight

Now, Neely’s legal team is pushing for his release, arguing that both he and the state’s mental health department assert he has the legal right to leave the hospital. On the other side, prosecutors are raising red flags about the potential risks of allowing Neely back into the community. They contend that he may pose a danger due to his history of noncompliance with medication and warnings that his mental health issues could resurface.

At the heart of the court proceedings is a thorough discussion of Neely’s past. Testimony during the previous trial revealed that he had been experiencing disturbing hallucinations, claiming that he heard voices and that “invisible people” were after him. A psychiatric evaluation conducted at the time confirmed that Neely was unable to distinguish right from wrong due to his mental illness when he committed the act.

Prospective Plans After Release

The judge’s decision will be pivotal as Neely’s proposed release would be to a community care facility located near Spartanburg. This facility would allow him some level of freedom, but it also requires that he continues to take anti-psychotic medication. A state psychiatrist testified that adherence to this medication regimen is critically important for Neely’s well-being and community safety.

The Opposition

However, the prosecution remains unconvinced. They pointed out several instances of Neely refusing medication even while in custody, including a recent incident where he tested positive for marijuana. These instances raise alarms about the viability of his treatment and whether he truly poses a risk to the public should he be released.

The Community’s Concern

The fear surrounding Neely’s potential return to the community is palpable. Renea Barber, the wife of one of the victims, shared her thoughts in court, expressing deep concerns about the danger Neely’s release could represent. It’s a sentiment echoed by many local residents who remember the tragic events that unfolded on that fateful day in 2019.

A Weighty Decision Ahead

As Judge Keith Kelly deliberates, the stakes are higher than ever. The decision will set a crucial precedent not only for Neely but also for community safety and mental health considerations throughout Rock Hill. Will Jimar Neely walk free, or will he remain under the care of mental health professionals? All eyes are on the courtroom as residents of Rock Hill hold their breath, awaiting the outcome of this complex and emotionally charged case.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

Additional Resources

• WBTV
• Herald Online
• WCNC
• WSOC-TV
• WCCB Charlotte
• Wikipedia: Mental Health
• Google Search: Insanity defense
• Google Scholar: Mental Health Law
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Insanity
• Google News: Rock Hill Jimar Neely