Rock Hill Library Board Struggles with Resignations and Contentious Book Policies

Rock Hill Library Board Faces Changes Amid Content Controversy

Rock Hill — The York County Library Board is undergoing a significant transformation as it convenes for the first time without two of its members, following recent conflicts regarding book restrictions for children. The board, which will meet at 6 p.m. at the Fort Mill Library on November 14, 2024, is set to elect a new chairperson during a session that currently has no new business on the agenda.

The departures of former chairwoman Anne Witte and member Charles Robinson have left the board with increasing tension. Both members resigned in light of heated discussions that took place over the previous month concerning the presence of certain books in the children’s sections of the county’s libraries. Witte and Robinson expressed frustration over what they perceived as censorship and a lack of direction within the board.

Board Changes and Challenges

As part of ongoing changes, the York County Council had previously reduced the board’s size from 10 to 7 members. This decision, along with the recent resignations, has resulted in Wendi Michael being the sole remaining member with more than a year and a half of experience on the board. The current board members also include Susan Piening, Timothy Steele, Carol Herring, and Dennis Getter.

Contentious debates surrounding book selections have heightened tensions, especially among parents and community stakeholders. A controversial law passed by the state General Assembly in June prohibits libraries from offering materials that may appeal to “prurient interest” for children under 13. Consequently, board members sought guidance from the state Attorney General’s office, but a lack of clarity has led to further complications.

Resignation Insights

Both Witte and Robinson cited dissatisfaction with how board operations have been conducted in their resignation letters. Robinson voiced concerns about the majority of the board members who had not completed their annual performance evaluations for the library director but were still seeking to influence how the library should be run. He described the situation as “totally unfair” and “unacceptable.”

Witte echoed similar sentiments, stating, “I do not have the appetite nor stomach for the conflict, division, and political agendas which are becoming the norm.” She firmly opposed what she referred to as “censorship” that counters the mission of the library board.

Future of Library Content

The board’s discussions have not only led to resignations but have also culminated in decisions regarding future book acquisitions. A recent vote passed a moratorium on purchasing specific books until they receive direction from the state. This motion was met with opposition from both Witte and Robinson, who feared it would inhibit the ability to acquire new children’s books altogether.

As the board prepares to meet once more, the upcoming discussions will likely revolve around not only the election of new leadership but also how to navigate the contentious issues surrounding book selection and community expectations. Parents and residents are watching closely to see how the library will address both public concerns and state mandates.

A Community Divide

This ongoing situation reflects a broader conflict seen in various school and public library systems across the state, showcasing the divide between advocates for parental control over children’s reading materials and those supporting broader access to literature without restrictions. As the York County Library Board moves forward, all eyes will be on their ability to come together to uphold the library’s founding principles while honoring the community’s diverse views.